Love Is Blind‘s Shayne Jansen is Instagram official with Julie Theis!

On Sunday, Oct. 13, Jansen revealed he’s dating the winner of the Netflix game show The Trust: A Game of Greed, with the pair sharing multiple cute photos on social media.

Jansen posted a carousel of images to Instagram, with one snap showing the pair posing for a selfie and smiling sweetly for the camera. A second photo showed Theis wrapping her arms lovingly around her new man while wearing a blue mini dress and heels, posing with one leg in the air.

Jansen stood proudly beside her, wearing a gray T-shirt and jeans and holding a drink.

A further image showed a shirtless Jansen carrying his partner as she smiled at him and again wrapped her arms around him, wearing a crop top and matching pants.

A final picture showed the reality star taking a photo of Theis, giving fans a glimpse of the image as she sat in front of him.

“Love is her ❤️,” Jansen captioned the post.

“My best friend ❤️” Theis wrote in the comments section. She also gushed about the pair’s romance on Instagram, sharing another photo of her wearing the blue dress, writing in the caption, “Mine.♥️”

“My love ❤️,” Jansen commented.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Theis then shared the post on her Instagram Stories, writing, “Surprise,” with a love heart emoji.

In another Instagram Stories video, Theis commented on fans’ “sweet and supportive” messages, but admitted people first thought she was Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Taylor Frankie Paul after Jansen posted about his new girlfriend on his Instagram Stories.

“I’m not completely mad because she has really good hair, and I have really good hair, so I see where it came from… but not one was like ‘Is that Julie?’ “

“Let’s get it together,” she jokingly added.

Jansen was previously engaged to his Love Is Blind costar Natalie Mina Lee after starring on the second season of the hit Netflix dating show.

After finally getting to meet in person, the pair had a massive argument before their wedding and Lee then refused to say “I do” at the altar, even though Jansen had already said the same words.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.

Meanwhile, Theis dated fellow The Trust star Jake Chocholous but told the Daily Mail in January that the pair had called it quits.

“We were on good terms leaving the show,” she told the outlet, adding, “We had this whole experience and when you come back, you can’t tell anyone that you’re on the show, so I was thankful for Jake in that regard.”

“But as far as pursuing something romantic, Jake and I have such severely different beliefs — and I want people to know that,” she added.